I have the worst luck finding self tanners. The color or the smell never work out. These are some of the ones I've tried, and didn't like.
Neutrogena, Banana Boat, Vaseline Healthy Glow - Sticky and gave me a yellow undertone
Ulta spay bronzer- this goes on unevenly and the nozzle broke
Loreal Sublime- smelled awful and streaky
The Aveeno brand moisturizing gradual tanners were the best. I love aveeno products, and these gave me an even color and made my skin super soft. It smells like a cream, not offensive at all. best of all you see color within 2 applications. The Dial Up Aveeno tanner works right away.