I needed a new black eyeliner for my waterline because my gel liner was beginning to bother me. Also my eyes are watering like crazy. I tried out 2 drugstore, Revlon Colorstay and Loreal Extra Intense($8-9), and 1 high end, MUFE Aqua Eyes($17). One stood out...
THE WINNER
Loreal Extra Intense Eyeliner in Black
- Super black
- Glides on
- Doesn't smudge
- Doesn't move
The biggest let down was the MUFE Aqua Eyes stay put liner. Just putting it on was a chore. I had to keep going over the waterline to get any color pay-off. Then it just slid right down. I don't get it, it says Stays put liner.
I have to say drugstore products have really improved, a lot!
What are you using on your water line or as an eyeliner?
9 comments:
I ♥ the L'oreal liner for my waterline and lashline as well - definitely performs better than MUFE or UD liners for me! When I have the time, Wet N Wild's creme liner or L'oreal's HIP liner in black also has serious staying power on my waterline.
I have all the above! And I agree the L'Oreal is really great. Revlon is drying, sometimes it pulls on my skin a bit more than I'd like but I try to warm it up with a hair dryer lol
I use Prestige waterproof eyeliner in black...it last pretty long before it starts to drift. I liked Revlon colorstay but it seemed to irritate my eyes. Will definitely give Loreal a try when my Prestige liner runs out :)
hey thanks for this. I will definitely check out l'oreal :)
Urban Decay's 24/7 is the only liner i know that stays put on my waterline. I want to try ELF's mineral liner though, and after seeing this I might pick up the L'Oreal one too.. :)
I use either the Revlon Colorstay or the Wet N Wild creme liner. I find the WNW stays the best out of anything I have ever tried. I tried the Milani Liquif'eye stuff and it just slid right off. Now I feel the need to try the L'Oreal one!
I love the Wet n Wild, really a great gel liner.
I'm so excited to hear this and will pick it up this weekend. Good to see I'm not the only one who was disappointed in MUFE!
I use Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner and Prestige Waterproof Eyeliner, they're both great! :) I have to try that L'Oreal eyeliner you mentioned! :)
Post a Comment