Monday, June 7, 2010

EYELINER Low & High End for the Waterline-The Winner Is?


I needed a new black eyeliner for my waterline because my gel liner was beginning to bother me.  Also my eyes are watering like crazy.  I tried out 2 drugstore, Revlon Colorstay and Loreal Extra Intense($8-9), and 1 high end, MUFE Aqua Eyes($17).  One stood out...


THE WINNER


Loreal Extra Intense Eyeliner in Black
  • Super black
  • Glides on
  • Doesn't smudge
  • Doesn't move
The Colorstay was in close second, but it's a little dry, but had great lasting power too.
The biggest let down was the MUFE Aqua Eyes stay put liner.  Just putting it on was a chore.  I had to keep going over the waterline to get any color pay-off.  Then it just slid right down.  I don't get it, it says Stays put liner.

I have to say drugstore products have really improved, a lot!  

What are you using on your water line or as an eyeliner?


9 comments:

mayaari said...

I ♥ the L'oreal liner for my waterline and lashline as well - definitely performs better than MUFE or UD liners for me! When I have the time, Wet N Wild's creme liner or L'oreal's HIP liner in black also has serious staying power on my waterline.

DSK said...

I have all the above! And I agree the L'Oreal is really great. Revlon is drying, sometimes it pulls on my skin a bit more than I'd like but I try to warm it up with a hair dryer lol

The Makeup Frugalista said...

I use Prestige waterproof eyeliner in black...it last pretty long before it starts to drift. I liked Revlon colorstay but it seemed to irritate my eyes. Will definitely give Loreal a try when my Prestige liner runs out :)

EveryDay Makeup (becky) said...

hey thanks for this. I will definitely check out l'oreal :)

Liza said...

Urban Decay's 24/7 is the only liner i know that stays put on my waterline. I want to try ELF's mineral liner though, and after seeing this I might pick up the L'Oreal one too.. :)

Jaime said...

I use either the Revlon Colorstay or the Wet N Wild creme liner. I find the WNW stays the best out of anything I have ever tried. I tried the Milani Liquif'eye stuff and it just slid right off. Now I feel the need to try the L'Oreal one!

GiGi said...

I love the Wet n Wild, really a great gel liner.

Michelle said...

I'm so excited to hear this and will pick it up this weekend. Good to see I'm not the only one who was disappointed in MUFE!

Stavroula said...

I use Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner and Prestige Waterproof Eyeliner, they're both great! :) I have to try that L'Oreal eyeliner you mentioned! :)

Related Posts with Thumbnails